25  Simpsons Lane

Property Photo

ONCE IN A LIFETIME OPPORTUNITY- to purchase The HISTORIC LIGHTKEEPERS INN RESIDENCE- or transform the property into a private residence in the heart of Edgartown. Thought to be the home of Henry Lyman Thomas, one of the last lightkeepers of the Edgartown Lighthouse. The two-level Main Building is comprised of five (5) one-bedroom suites/apartments each with a private entrance and offering a living/dining area with kitchen — plus a bedroom and full bath. The rear of the property has a 738 square foot, stand-alone one-bedroom cottage with private deck and yard. Each efficiency unit offers its own entrance. There is also a shared outdoor area for BBQ and gathering. Guests can stroll to town for their morning coffee, walk picturesque North Water Street to the Edgartown Lighthouse, spend the day on the nearby beach or explore the Island from this convenient location. With a strong repeat rental history including summers and the “off season” the new owners could decide to keep the Inn as it is or the opportunity exists to turn the property into a single-family residence (with proper permitting and approvals). Schedule a visit to learn more about this unique offering in the heart of the Edgartown village.


  • House Type: Commercial
  • Town: Edgartown
  • Property Address: 25 Simpsons Lane
  • Price: $3,489,000
  • LINK ID: 38967
  • Bedrooms: 6
  • Baths: 6
  • Rooms: 12
  • Living Space: 3156
  • Acres: 0.2007
  • Water Frontage: None
  • Heat: OilFHW
  • Year Built: 1900
  • Year Renovated: 1986


Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Point B Realty LLC