West Tisbury Properties for Sale

Address: 60 Bartimus Luce Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41317

Price: $24,500,000

Property Description:
This North Shore beachfront estate represents one of the most breathtaking properties in all of New England. The newly built home was created on a 3.3-acre parcel of land, surrounded by specimen trees, rolling grassy meadows and is highly situated on a stable bank overlooking nearly 250 ft of sandy ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Landvest MV

Address: 104 & 111 Old Herring Creek Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 42055

Price: $21,500,000

Property Description:
This beautiful 2-parcel compound totals 9.5-acre of land and 600 feet of private Vineyard Sound beach. There is a renovated 4-bedroom beach cottage on one of the parcels which includes all modern amenities and offers spectacular views from almost every room. The second parcel has an older 3-bedroom ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Landvest MV

Address: 104 Pond View Farm Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41979

Price: $5,300,000

Property Description:
An exceptional waterfront opportunity on the Tisbury Great Pond with two homes and a permitted dock where one can keep a boat, and motor out to the south shore Atlantic sandy beach. There are strong views of the water from both the main home and guest house where one can enjoy the abundant bird and ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Tea Lane Associates

Address: 41 Naushon Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 42144

Price: $4,995,000

Property Description:
Spectacular waterfront home perfectly set in Upper Makonikey along West Tisbury’s north shore. Perched with immediate, jaw-dropping views of Vineyard Sound, sailboats, ferries and more, this sprawling 6 bedroom home offers quintessential seaside living. The main living room, set just below the hom... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | MV Team

Address: 1070 State Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 42174

Price: $3,950,000

Property Description:
The West Tisbury Inn located in the village of West Tisbury. This unique offering includes three buildings on a prominent setting across from the Grange Hall and Town Hall. The Inn’s primary structure, a Victorian style farmhouse which dates to 1784, was totally renovated in 1998. There are seven ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | MV Team

Address: 67 Hidden Village Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41843

Price: $3,650,000

Property Description:
Picturesquely sited on a spacious 4.6-acre parcel, this remarkable property is the perfect Vineyard retreat offering a luxurious home, guest house, fenced pastures, and a large barn. Just minutes from Lamberts Cove Beach, hiking trails, Up-Island Cronig’s, and all the conveniences of West Tisbury ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Donnelly + Co

Address: 40 Waldrons Bottom Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41388

Price: $3,500,000

Property Description:
Long Point Beach ~ Main House and Guest House. Centrally located and convenient to all island towns this 5.4 acre property offers privacy between the two dwellings. The expansive Main House sits on a knoll with a large lawn for family fun as well as a basketball court. There are two master ensuite b... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Donnelly + Co

Address: 18 South Pond Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41586

Price: $3,395,000

Property Description:
Custom contemporary 5-bedroom home with heated Pebbletec pool and Deep Bottom Pond Association Access to Tisbury Great Pond. This spacious layout boasts two primary bedroom suites, two guestrooms, and a private guest suite. The open floor plan is perfect for accommodating a large group and entertain... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Sandpiper Realty

Address: 23 Alex Way Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41878

Price: $2,950,000

Property Description:
23 Alex Way is an opportunity to embrace the extraordinary Elias/Langmuir/Skinner legacy which dramatically changed this extensive rural West Tisbury landscape. The 140 acres was purchased in 1972 and became the Nat's Farm homeowner community of 26 home sites which included 56 acres donated later to... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Tea Lane Associates

Address: 157 Ben Chase Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41459

Price: $2,850,000

Property Description:
An idyllic, ultimately private compound with lovely topography abuts 87 acres of conservation land. An extensive renovation was completed in 2021 by a meticulous hand honoring the property's timeless quality. This magical realm includes a lovely pond viewed from the sunny Main House w/ a 20'x 30' ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Tashmoo Realty

Address: 23 Oak Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 42131

Price: $2,850,000

Property Description:
Oasis in the woods of West Tisbury! This meticulously constructed, updated and well-maintained home is set on an expansive, yet private, 2.7 acre parcel. This 6-bedroom home has three levels of living space, 2,363 square feet on the spacious first floor, 672 over the garage and 1,877 in the bright, ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Sandpiper Realty

Address: 26 Chappaquiddick Avenue Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41614

Price: $2,725,000

Property Description:
Waterview and waterfront property that is protected from the elements and set amongst some of the finest homes in Makonikey! Complete with fully approved plans by Moskow Linn Architects for a new 4 bedroom home with pool and 2 bed. carriage house, this private compound includes three existing dwelli... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | MV Team

Address: 11 Beach Pebble Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41593

Price: $2,500,000

Property Description:
Over 3 acres in the West Tisbury section of Makonikey. This buildable lot is a short distance from the Lower Makonikey Association beach. The property is in an area of several multimillion-dollar homes and will accommodate a house, guesthouse, and swimming pool. The neighboring 3.2-acre lot (48.5) w... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Wallace & Co. Sotheby's

Address: 11 Oak Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 42213

Price: $2,475,000

Property Description:
Love this West Tisbury Location! Home business opportunity awaits. Consider this possibility to be in a sought-after convenient area of West Tisbury that offers a variety of options for a new owner.   Well-appointed and in excellent condition, this three-bedroom and three bathroom main home and a s... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Tea Lane Associates

Address: 3 Danls Way Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41699

Price: $2,200,000

Property Description:
HEART OF WEST TISBURY~A Truly Rare Purchase Opportunity in a Treasured West Tisbury Location…… This pastoral estate has been lovingly maintained by the same family for over 200 years! You will immerse yourself in this idyllic setting and enjoy living in this wonderful location. Sweeping views ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Ocean Park Realty Inc

Address: 7 Parsonage Woods Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41508

Price: $2,200,000

Property Description:
This rare and cherished setting is truly in the heart of West Tisbury. With old growth cedar, oaks and evergreen trees this level 4.8 acre parcel includes a main house and timber barn, perfectly sited to enjoy serene views and southern exposure. New roof and SOLAR PANELS installed November 2023 mak... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | MV Team

Address: 75 Skiffs Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41787

Price: $1,975,000

Property Description:
Located on a beautiful, private 2.6 acre lot, this well-maintained home is move-in ready and awaiting your personal touch! Pool, manicured yard, plentiful parking, attached garage, large basement, outdoor shower and many more features make this spacious family home versatile and accommodating to you... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Match Point Properties

Address: 5 Scottys Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41403

Price: $1,950,000

Property Description:
Imagine enjoying your morning routine on the oversized porch, overlooking Seth's Pond. The layout is designed for both privacy and togetherness, with a welcoming living room and dining area. Immerse yourself in the beauty of the outdoors. The spacious yard offers room for play and relaxation, and ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: eXp Realty

Address: 69 Island Farms Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 42112

Price: $1,899,900

Property Description:
Welcome to this beautifully renovated 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home nestled on a tranquil dead-end street, offering a spacious .92-acre lot and a fabulous finished basement. This property is the epitome of modern comfort and convenience, where every detail has been thoughtfully considered. As you appro... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Premiere Broker Inc

Address: 219 Oak Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41408

Price: $1,649,000

Property Description:
Discover Your Up Island Retreat: Nestled in the heart of West Tisbury, this exceptional 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom, 2500-square-foot home awaits your personal touch to complete its remarkable transformation. Abutting a picturesque horse pasture, this property offers a tranquil escape from the daily hustl... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | Point B

Address: 38 Fire Tower Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41999

Price: $1,595,000

Property Description:
The Tower Hill land, once known as the Dancing Hills, is considered by many a sacred Island space. Standing on the ridge top, you're at one of the highest points on Martha's Vineyard. This 3.01 acre parcel looks out over the trees of Red Farm and the dramatic blue expanse of Vineyard Sound. It's eas... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Tea Lane Associates

Address: 46 Crow Hollow Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41442

Price: $1,549,000

Property Description:
Welcome to a delightful Cape-style home nestled in this serene and picturesque area. This beautiful property offers the perfect blend of classic charm and modern comfort, making it an ideal retreat for those seeking the quintessential Vineyard experience. Situated on a peaceful, tree-lined cul-de-sa... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | Point B

Address: 188 Waldrons Bottom Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41227

Price: $1,525,000

Property Description:
Welcome to 188 Waldrons Bottom Road near the south shore in West Tisbury. Nestled on a private 3-acre property with access to Long Point Beach, this home offers incredible potential for a serene lifestyle. This unique property features a 1-bedroom (the property has a 2-bedroom septic), 1.5-bathroom ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | Point B

Address: 986 State Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 42057

Price: $1,495,000

Property Description:
WEST TISBURY VILLAGE; Home to this vintage charmer on over 4 acres. Cross gabled and retaining the appeal of a family farmhouse with modifications for current use. Generous rooms and interior space provide opportunities for future changes and system upgrades. Original refinished wood floors, first f... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | MV Team

Address: 9 Galway Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41877

Price: $1,395,000

Property Description:
Tucked away off Old County Road in West Tisbury, this 3 bedroom 1 bath cape home has been owned by the same family for years. Sitting on 1.6 acres in a quiet area that is centrally located on the Island for easy access to up or down Island towns. Short walk to bike path and state forest. West Tisbur... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Flanders Real Estate

Address: 25 Plum Bush Point Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41768

Price: $1,325,000

Property Description:
This beautiful wooded 4.12 acre parcel of land is peaceful and serene, and ready to build. The well is installed, boundaries staked, perc test approved for a five-bedroom home and a septic plan designed. The large, flat building envelope on this parcel offers many siting possibilities, the ability t... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Tea Lane Associates

Address: 46 Old Coach Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 42064

Price: $1,295,000

Property Description:
Charming and Spacious 3-Bedroom Cape with large Loft and Deck Welcome to your dream West Tisbury home! This comfortable and spacious 3-bedroom, 2-bath Cape boasts a thoughtfully designed floor plan perfect for comfortable living. The first-floor features two bedrooms and a full bath, ideal for use ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: C McManus Realty Group

Address: 43 Pin Oak Circle Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 42097

Price: $1,289,000

Property Description:
West Tisbury with bells and whistles! This well tended to property has seen a LONG LIST of recent IMPROVEMENTS to make ownership easy and up-island life a breeze! Nicely tucked in and off of Old County Road means easy access to up island and down. The raised ranch style provides terrific living spac... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | MV Team

Address: 496 Lamberts Cove Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 40045

Price: $1,225,000

Property Description:
Two peaceful acres on coveted Lamberts Cove Road with access to Lamberts Cove Beach and proximity to West Tisbury Center and Conservation Land. This property boasts mature plantings, various trees, and much Mother Nature offers, including a small pond. The home was completely renovated in 2012 and e... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Donnelly + Co

Address: 25 North Vine Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 42093

Price: $1,199,000

Property Description:
25 North Vine Lane an exceptional 3.830 Acre Parcel with a gentle slope located in West Tisbury. On a dead end private location close to Town with quick access to Sepiessa Point, Tiah's Cove boat launches and Long Point Nature Preserve. This unspoiled tranquil piece of land is a clean canvas for you... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Seacoast Properties

Address: 87 Longview Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 41863

Price: $739,000

Property Description:
This lovely 1.60 acre wooded parcel is located in an outstanding neighborhood off Lambert's Cove Road with paved roads and easy access to beautiful Lambert's Cove Beach, less than a mile away. This lot is ready to build on. It has been staked, there is an approved septic design for 4 bedrooms, well... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Karen M. Overtoom R.E.