West Tisbury Properties for Sale

Address: 104 and 111 Old Herring Creek Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39574

Price: $26,500,000

Property Description:
Private waterfront estate comprised of two parcels in the prestigious North Shore neighborhood. This beautiful compound is spread over 9.5 acres of pristine land and includes over 600 feet of private Vineyard Sound beach.  The elegantly refurbished beach house has all the modern conveniences and fe... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Wallace & Co. Sotheby's

Address: 104 Old Herring Creek Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39788

Price: $16,500,000

Property Description:
Private waterfront estate in the prestigious North Shore neighborhood. This beautiful compound is spread over 5.3 acres of pristine land and includes over 425 square feet of private Vineyard Sound beach. The elegantly refurbished beach house has all the modern conveniences and features spectacular ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Wallace & Co. Sotheby's

Address: 78 Bartimus Luce Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39567

Price: $11,900,000

Property Description:
Panoramic views and spectacular sunsets await at the Bartimus Luce Estate. Situated between Upper Makonikey and Lambert’s Cove this idyllic family property dates to the 1600’s when it was first settled and farmed. The compound is set on a wooded bluff overlooking the Vineyard Sound and Elizabeth... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Donnelly + Co

Address: 111 Old Herring Creek Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39791

Price: $10,000,000

Property Description:
Private waterfront Beach Cottage in the prestigious North Shore neighborhood. Spread over 4.3 acres of land and includes over 160 feet of private Vineyard Sound beach. This unique guest cottage includes a roof deck overlooking the property, Vineyard Sound and the Elizabeth Islands. Enjoy a magical ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Wallace & Co. Sotheby's

Address: 28 Hillbrook Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39615

Price: $9,500,000

Property Description:
Located off of beautiful Indian Hill Road, this wonderful Family Estate, comprised of three separate properties, totaling over 20 acres, offers the ultimate in privacy. The driveway winds past weathered stone walls, mature trees and down gently sloped terrain to the various improvements that exists.... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Landvest MV

Address: 48 Forest Road SGF Site 37 Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39028

Price: $7,500,000

Property Description:
Seven Gates Farm waterfront and rare opportunities are synonyms. This coveted community offers nearly 2,000 acres of the Island's most beautiful, dramatic conservation land including two miles of walkable beach, two docks, two tennis courts and extensive trails. The Revere waterfront home, an origin... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Donnelly + Co

Address: 41 Naushon Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39352

Price: $5,495,000

Property Description:
Spectacular waterfront home perfectly set in Upper Makonikey along West Tisbury’s north shore. Perched with immediate, jaw-dropping views of Vineyard Sound, sailboats, ferries and more, this sprawling 6 bedroom home offers quintessential seaside living with unique flair. The main living room, set ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | MV Team

Address: 175 Pond Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 38720

Price: $3,594,500

Property Description:
Exquisite home with swimming pool in the perfect location in West Tisbury! Set on one of the rarely offered field view parcels in Deep Bottom Pond, this gracious residence in one of the island's most sought after enclaves exudes quality at every turn. Constructed by noted contractor Rosbeck Builders... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass | MV Team

Address: 6 North Vine Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39145

Price: $3,095,000

Property Description:
Exquisitely maintained and charming main house, guest house(built in 2006), barn and 3-car garage are all in perfect, move-in condition. Located in the heart of West Tisbury, off a private, paved lane, the stunning oak post-and-beam main house and other handsome buildings are spacious and bright wi... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Tea Lane Associates

Address: 566 Scrubby Neck Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39878

Price: $2,849,000

Property Description:
Options abound with this oversized 6.37 acre parcel located just 1/10 mile from the entrance to the magnificent Long Point beach. The property is bordered to the east by a 35 acre parcel owned by the Nature Conservancy. With the current three acre minimum zoning requirement in West Tisbury, subdivis... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Sandpiper Realty

Address: 55 Old House Way Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 38878

Price: $2,750,000

Property Description:
Lambert’s Cove/West Tisbury home custom- built contemporary farmhouse style has 4 bedrooms & 3 bathrooms in the main house. Shares 3 acres with a 2 bedrooms &1 bath guest cottage in a private neighborhood. Enter Main house from the covered porch -matching custom arch doors lead you to either the ... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Anchor Realty of Martha's Vineyard

Address: 40 Dolphine Merry Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39332

Price: $2,500,000

Property Description:
Charming Lambert's Cove property features a pastoral landscape of rolling lawns and gardens, stone walls, and mature oaks with room for a possible pool. Highly desired location, just a short walk to Seth's Pond and one mile to Lambert Cove Beach and Up Island Cronig's Market. Entering the main house... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Elevated Realty LLC

Address: 225 Great Plains Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39888

Price: $2,445,000

Property Description:
This meticulously maintained four bedroom home was fully renovated in 2018 making it move in ready and is being sold turnkey. It sits back on a 2.92 acre wooded parcel in a quiet neighborhood with a paved road offering plenty of privacy while being only about a ten minute drive to either Vineyard Ha... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Karen M. Overtoom R.E.

Address: 10 Crow Hollow Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39581

Price: $2,400,000

Property Description:
Located in a popular area of West Tisbury, this 1.3+ acre parcel has a lovely, well designed main house, a workshop, garage and chicken house. There is potential for a detached bedroom or small business on the property if one seeks necessary permits. The property is well maintained with nice lands... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Flanders Real Estate

Address: 74 Waldrons Bottom Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39934

Price: $1,995,000

Property Description:
Start your day with bird song and the rustling of the trees on the South Shore of West Tisbury. This charming, spacious and elegant family home sits on over 2 acres, and has been lovingly cared for and maintained by one family since the home was built. The property abuts 100+ acres of Nature Conserv... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Tea Lane Associates

Address: 259 State Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39718

Price: $1,899,000

Property Description:
Solar-powered in West Tisbury! Recently renovated in 2021, this three-bedroom, three-bath home is move-in ready. The unique layout lends itself to a savvy buyer, with a fully finished 2,000+ sq. f.t basement and a workshop attached to the first floor. Renovations include Mini- Splits Heat/AC and Irr... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Compass LLC

Address: 299 Oak Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39480

Price: $1,549,000

Property Description:
If you've dreamed of a peaceful and quiet setting look no further. This 5 bdrm, 3 bath home is set back on a secluded 1.59-acre lot at the very end of the road. Step out of the backyard and directly into 5000 acres of state forest with many breathtaking nature trails, bridle paths, and miles of bike... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Vineyard Real Estate

Address: 46 Crow Hollow Road Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39884

Price: $1,495,000

Property Description:
If you have been seeking a quiet island hideaway in the lush woodlands of West Tisbury near the South Shore, pristine wildlife refuges and magnificent beaches, then this will check all your boxes. This nicely maintained and updated two-bedroom, two-bath home needs nothing for your enjoyment. The pro... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Sandpiper Realty

Address: 15 Alex Way Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39869

Price: $875,000

Property Description:
Lovely, wooded, level lot with a southerly orientation and a small view channel of the Nat's Farm meadow over abutting property. Staked and tagged; perc test ordered and well site being determined. This is the last undeveloped lot in Nat's Farm - an area of fine homes with conservation meadows on b... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Karen M. Overtoom R.E.

Address: 296 Oak Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 39682

Price: $775,000

Property Description:
3.3 acres in West Tisbury! This level, wooded lot is versatile and ready for your dream home! It allows for lots of bedrooms, living space, and an array of accessory structures. 50' setbacks from all sides. Not enough land for a guest house. Close to the State Forest and bike path! Property is stake... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Viewpoints

Address: 209 Oak Lane Town: West Tisbury Link ID: 38377

Price: $599,000

Property Description:
1.5-acres on Oak Lane. This unspoiled piece of land is in a charming part of the island. Well is in place. Building permit and septic permit for a 3-bedroom house were issued by Town of WT but have expired. Note: Following the execution of the P&S, a Buyer will need to apply to the Town of West Tisb... Click here for more details

Property description and photographs provided by listing agent: Wallace & Co. Sotheby's